View All
| |
Posted by
Anek Anand
27 Jul 2010
|
|
|
| service tax for T-19 |
| Apart from regular demand letter, I have received letter from triveni to pay service tax also which is new thing to me.Could you throw some light on this new demand to pay service tax? |
Reply: any installments wef july 1 2010, with now invite a component of service tax, this was announced in latest union budget. You can read other posts in this blog.
|
|
|
| 1 |
|
Admin
Posted:
02 Mar 2010
|
|
|
Construction services tax to raise cost of apartments
|
|
THE Budget proposals have thrown up a dampener for the housing industry. Construction services have now been brought under the ambit of the service tax in an unexpected move that would raise cost of apartments that are still under construction. As per the Budget proposal, the finance ministry has suggested that construction would be deemed to be a taxable service if the building or complex is still under construction and approval from the concerned regulatory authority — which in most cases is the resident municipal authority — hasn’t yet been granted. The levy would cover all construction of complex service or commercial or industrial construction services, the Finance Bill suggested.
The service tax levy would be 10.3% and would also apply to additional services such as those offering preferential locations for flats in multi-storey buildings where flats in each floor are priced at a premium due to their location. This too has been described as a service and hence taxable, according to the proposal which was tabled in Parliament on Friday by finance minister Pranab Mukherjee. The premium is typically levied on categories such as flats or apartments that are above a certain floor rise or have other high value locations such as being in front of a garden or a sea or any other preferred locality.
“The proposal is to tax construction if the entire payment for the flat is made before completion of construction,” said consulting firm RSM Astute executive director K H Viswanathan. “This would increase the cost of the apartment and may discourage potential buyers.” The service tax would be 10% on 33% of the price of the apartment, while on the remaining 67%, tax won’t be levied.
Till now, for all apartments under construction, customers paid in instalments based on plinth level construction and also on the progress in building activity. Banks too lent money to the customers according to the requirement of the builder. Now most developers would ask customers to pay the entire value of the building if they sought to lock in at a certain value. This would mean paying the entire sum before the construction. Typically, in cities such as Mumbai, where there is a pressure on space and hence apartments and flats are much sought after, customers booking for flats in an under-construction building, is very common. “The service tax and excise duty hike on cement would increase the overall cost of apartment by about 10%,” said Dharmesh Jain, managing director of Nirmal Lifestyles, a Mumbai-based developer. “It’s a negative step and we are considering to meet the finance minister to plead for a relook on this measure,” he added. But there are other positive measures that the Budget proposes such as allowing pending projects to be completed within a period of 5 years instead of 4 years, for claiming deduction of profits, as one time interim relief. There is also a suggestion that the commercial area included in a housing project would now be 3% of the aggregate built-up area of the housing project or 5,000 sq. ft, whichever is higher, compared to the existing limit of 2% and 2,000 sq.ft. respectively. This would help developers and real estate companies to make their projects more viable.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Want to Comment
|
| Most Recent comment |
| |
|
Service Tax
Posted by
Amit Jain
05 Sep 2010
|
|
|
| I made a pre-launch booking for a 2 bhk flat in BPTP's Princess Park , Fbd. in Jan 2006. The contract was signed in Sept.2007. Till now , I have paid about 85% cost.
Will there be any Service Tax in this case and if so on which component and how much. (So far no service tax has been raised or paid). In other words what are the broad rules of Service Tax in cases likes mine. |
Reply: whatever payment is to be made to developer after 1 july would attract a service tax of around 2.7 percent on any installment or payment.
|
|
|
|
|
Service tax
Posted by
Sunny
28 Aug 2010
|
|
|
| Just wanted to check the impact of Service Tax. Are builder allow to charge tax? I remember(one of the users), posted a link wherein it was mentioned that Bombay HC had put on hold levy of service tax
Would be great if you can share the link and advise on the query |
Reply: all developers in our belt still charging. not sure if mumbai HC is valid only locally or whole of india.
|
|
|
|
|
Service tax
Posted by
sona
23 Aug 2010
|
|
|
| Mumbai High Court has stayed levying service tax till further orders. This article has appeared in The Times of India dated 14th Aug 2010 under Property section. No builder can charge service tax as told by Honble court. BUt BPTP is asking for Service tax for all installments after 1st July and when I talked to them they said there is no notification for this. Can you confirm that Service tax is waived off and is there anybody(BPTP customer or otherwise) who has paid the installment without srvice tax. |
Reply: it would make sense if someone can post a link to actual judgement or notification instead of quoting a news article bcoz i doubt a developer would stay collection of tax just based on a news article.
|
|
|
|
|
SERVICE TAX
Posted by
SUNIL KUMAR
16 Aug 2010
|
|
|
| Hello friends, this information is all for those readers who have been charged service tax in their Demand Letter. Mumbai High Court has stayed levying service tax till further orders. This article has appeared in The Times of India dated 14th Aug 2010 under Property section. No builder can charge service tax as told by Honble court. So donot give service tax till the issue is pending with the court |
Reply: Thanks for the update. can you provide a link of the news item for reference of all. I would also trying to locate.
|
|
|
|
|
service tax for T-19
Posted by
Anek Anand
27 Jul 2010
|
|
|
| Apart from regular demand letter, I have received letter from triveni to pay service tax also which is new thing to me.Could you throw some light on this new demand to pay service tax? |
Reply: any installments wef july 1 2010, with now invite a component of service tax, this was announced in latest union budget. You can read other posts in this blog.
|
|
|
|
|
Omaxe Heights
Posted by
deepak sinha
01 Jul 2010
|
|
|
| Omaxe SMSing the customer to pay the due amount before 1st of July. I have not made the payment because I wanted to pay only when the construction is reached the status and the actual payment due request is raised. Do you think it was the right decision or paying the dues to save service tax would have been the better option? |
Reply: It is a wise decision. we never suggest paying what is not due. else one should rather avail downpmt discount.
|
|
|
|
|
serive tax
Posted by
D Gill
01 Jul 2010
|
|
|
| Does service tax apply on under constructed flats also, specifically in case of Omaxe Hills(old) where the buyer had already paid more than 70% of the total cost and moreover agreement does not have any mention of the same, which was signed long back in 2007. |
Reply: any outstanding installments of any under construction project should attract service tax. any agreement would have somewhere or the other covered a clause on any possible addition of govt levy whatsoever.
|
|
|
|
|
Service Tax
Posted by
RAJESH VOHRA
30 Jun 2010
|
|
|
| I have seen a couple of queries on applicability of Service Tax on installments paid on or after 1 July 2010. I have also been receiving emails from Omaxe to pay all the due/undue installments on or before 30 June 2010 to avoid paying Service Tax on the same. In order to put the things in the right perspective, I would like to bring to the notice of the forum, following points :
1 Service Tax gets triggered on the rendering of the service and not on actual payment. Therefore, if the construction service is rendered after 1 July 2010, the revenue authorities can still demand Service Tax on the corresponding installment paid, even if it is paid in advance before 1 July 2010.
2 Service tax is not leviable on the entire installment as 75% abatement is available. Moreover, no Service Tax is payable on Parking charges. In other words, Service tax is payable @ 10.3 % of only 25% of the installment (after excluding parking charges), thus bringing down the effective rate to less than 2.575 % of the installment. Any Service tax levied may therefore be substantially or fully offset by the interest earned / saved on postponement of the payment of installment.
3 Service Tax is a levy on the Service Provider (Omaxe in the instant case) and not on the Service Receiver (the individual buyer, in the instant case) even though contractually it is customary that it is passed on by the Service Provider to the Service Receiver. However, in case of litigation with the revenue authorities, it is only the Service Provider who can be held accountable.
4 For most of the allottees of Omaxe Heights, the due date of handing over possession (as per the Builder-buyer agreement) has already elapsed. Thus, had the possession been offered as per the time schedule without delays, there would have been no question of payment of Service Tax. Thus, even commercially, Omaxe may not be able to justify passing on its Service Tax liability to the individual allottees as the same has become payable because of the delays by Omaxe.
Hope this will help all the forum members in taking a financially prudent informed decision in the matter.
|
Reply: As much as i understand service tax would be applicable on installments called after july 1. It would also be applicable on endorsement (transfer) fees. It is the cost and liability of the service receiver (it is not just customary to pass). be it mobile bills, insurance premiums etc etc it is customer liability. however, it is the liability and responsbility of the service provider to collect and deposit the same. I have never suggested paying non due installment for the same logic that interest component of money could be lesser than service tax impact. I dont see an escape to service tax as a whole, either case, unless someone contests it in the court.
|
|
|
|
|
Service Tax
Posted by
Jasmeet
29 Jun 2010
|
|
|
| Could u share some clarity on service tax implication on the property purchased before the announcement and the implication on the outstanding amount/balance amount. |
Reply: implication by and large remain applicable to any demands raised by developer after implementation date which is 1st july to the best of our knowledge.
|
|
|
|
|
Tax
Posted by
sudhanshu
25 Jun 2010
|
|
|
| Has the additional proposed property tax become functional? |
Reply: If you are referring to service tax, i doubt it has been implemented as of now.
|
|
|
|
| 1 2 |
|
|
|